Honestly speaking, Kanebo Lunasol Stain Color Lips has been my favorite. I mostly use pink (3 first shades) because it's so Japanese looking!!! 

Not only it's super moisturizing, but it's buttery smooth! The color might look only slightly different but in fact it compliments each skin shade pretty well once you get the best shade

Also it's matte finish but not like western matte but more into asian matte, which still has a little bit of moisture and healthy finish, though not glossy

You just have to try it by yourself, maybe you can test it at the counter first and if you dont like it, you can just run HAHAHA (though im sure youll like it ^^)